How many arbitrators should I find?

An arbitrator plays the same roll as a trial court judge. They listen to the case and make a final decision. When there are more than one arbitrator required, they will each reach their own independent decision and then whoever has the majority vote will be the prevailing party.

If you are given the discretion of selecting the arbitrator or of choosing one of the three arbitrators, there are many ways to determine if they will be more favorable to your side. First, inquire about the arbitrator’s experience. Most arbitrators are retired judges or attorneys. If the arbitration proceeding will deal with highly specialized information, then locate an arbitrator who is familiar with your area of law. If you are still at a loss for choosing an arbitrator, consult with your attorney about your choice. Remember that the arbitration proceeding will be handled like a trial, so it only makes sense that you proceed with an attorney. The legal community in cities is quite small and attorneys will usually know who a favorable arbitrator may be. Finally, if you are planning on going with a retired judge arbitrator, run a search for them online. See what types of cases they listened to as a judge and perhaps even if there are any comments about how they responded to cases.

Case Studies: Understanding Arbitration and Arbitrators

Case Study 1: Arbitration With a Single Arbitrator

Sarah’s dispute was subject to an arbitration agreement that required the involvement of a single arbitrator. She sought the expertise of an attorney experienced in arbitration matters to guide her through the process. The arbitrator, an experienced retired judge, carefully listened to the arguments presented by both parties and ultimately rendered a final decision. Despite Sarah’s efforts, the arbitrator’s ruling favored the other party, highlighting the importance of effective presentation and strategic selection of an arbitrator.

Case Study 2: Tripartite Arbitration Panel

Michael’s case involved a tripartite arbitration panel. Each party selected their own arbitrator, and the two party-appointed arbitrators then selected a neutral third arbitrator. Michael’s legal team thoroughly researched potential arbitrators and strategically chose individuals with expertise in his specific area of law. The panel carefully reviewed the evidence and arguments from both sides and made a final decision based on the majority vote. In this case, the tripartite arbitration process provided a balanced and fair resolution.

Case Study 3: Federal Arbitration Appeal

Emily’s case involved arbitration in a Federal court. Seeking a favorable outcome, she appealed the arbitration decision to a Federal appellate court. With the guidance of an experienced attorney in Federal appellate matters, Emily navigated the complex procedures and presented compelling arguments. The appellate court carefully reviewed the evidence and overturned the initial arbitration decision, highlighting the significance of skilled legal representation and the potential for a successful appeal.