Best New Car Replacement Coverage in 2025 (Compare the Top 10 Companies)

Find the best new car replacement coverage with rates starting at $110 monthly or 7% of your premium.

Allstate offers great value with affordable rates and full protection. Farmers and Amica also provide competitive coverage options.

Read More: Full Coverage Auto Insurance

Our Top 10 Company Picks: Best New Car Replacement Coverage

Pick the best coverage to protect your new car.

Ready to shop around for the best new car replacement coverage? Enter your ZIP code and see which one offers the coverage you need.

#1 – Allstate: Top Overall Pick

Pros

• Robust Coverage Options: Allstate provides extensive policy features for the best new car replacement, rates at $120/month.
  
• Discount Options: Enjoy a 9% discount for comprehensive new car replacement coverage with Allstate.
  
• Local Agents: Allstate auto insurance review excels in offering personalized service with the help of local agents when insurance car replacement is in demand.

Cons

• Customer Service: Some customers report less-than-ideal experiences with Allstate’s claims process.
  
• Claims Process: Some policyholders have reported slower claims processing times for new car replacements.

Enter your ZIP code below to compare cheap insurance rates.

Auto Home Health Life Business Motorcycle Pet Medicare Rental

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

#2 – Farmers: Best for Competitive Rates

Pros

• Flexible Coverage Options: Farmers allow policyholders to customize the best new car replacement coverage rates at $125/month.
  
• Discount Options: Farmers provide a 12% discount on the best new car replacement coverage.
  
• Quick Claims Processing: Farmers ensure fast claims processing for replacement vehicle insurance scenarios. View our guide, “What types of car insurance coverage does Farmers Insurance offer?“

Cons

• Premium Rates: Farmers may have higher premiums for higher levels of coverage, especially in urban areas.
  
• Limited Digital Features: Online tools may lack the sophistication of other insurers, particularly when managing auto replacement protection.

#3 – Amica: Best for Innovative Tool

Pros

• Competitive Rates: Amica offers new car replacement coverage at $115/month.
  
• Discount Options: Amica provides an 8% discount on the best new car replacement coverage.
  
• Transparent policies: Amica is known for having clear and simple explanations of policies, thus making car insurance with new car replacements easy to understand.

Cons

• Availability: Amica may not be available for new car replacement coverage in all states.
  
• Fewer Discounts: There are limited discount options for bundling multiple policies. Read our guide for more details, “Does Amica Mutual Insurance offer non-owner car insurance coverage?“

#4 – Liberty Mutual: Best for Replacement Guarantee

Pros

• Extensive Coverage: Liberty Mutual auto insurance review offers robust new vehicle replacement insurance plans at rates starting at $130/month.
• Discount Options: Liberty Mutual provides a substantial 15% discount on new car replacement coverage.
• Accident Forgiveness: Protects against premium increases after the first at-fault accident with auto replacement protection.

Cons

• Higher Premiums: Liberty Mutual’s new car replacement coverage rates are among the highest.
  
• Limited Discounts for New Drivers: New drivers may not qualify for as many discounts in new car replacement coverage.

Enter your ZIP code below to compare cheap insurance rates.

Auto Home Health Life Business Motorcycle Pet Medicare Rental

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

#5 – Erie: Best for Affordable Replacement

Pros

• Affordable Premiums: Erie offers new car replacement coverage, rates at $110/month.
  
• Discount Options: Get a 7% discount on new car replacement coverage with Erie.
  
• Flexible Add-ons: Customize policies with options like replacement vehicle insurance.

Cons

• Regional Availability: Erie’s coverage is not available in all states. Check out our guide “Bundling Home and Auto Insurance With Erie,” which states that auto replacement protection is a limited option.
• Technology Limitations: The online platform may lack advanced features for digital-savvy users interested in efficiently managing new vehicle replacement coverage.

#6 – American Family: Best for Customer Focused

Pros

• Affordable Rates: American Family offers new car replacement coverage rates at $120 per month, which keeps rates competitive.
  
• Family-Oriented Features: The American Family policy includes teen driver and family car coverage with replacement auto coverage.
  
• Discount Options: A 9% discount on new car replacement coverage with American Family is available.

Cons

• Limited Availability: Coverage is not available in all states. View our guide “What types of car insurance coverage does American Family Insurance offer?“
• Higher Premiums: American Family premiums are relatively high compared to some competitors for new car replacements.

#7 – Progressive: Best for Flexible Policies

Pros

• Competitive Rates: Progressive offers new car replacement insurance with coverage that rates start at $118/month
  
• Discount Options: Progressive offers a 10% discount for new car replacement coverage.
  
• Snapshot Program: Progressive’s telematics program rewards safe drivers with discounts, enhancing the benefits of replacement vehicle insurance.
  

Cons

• Mixed Customer Reviews: Customer service varies greatly. Check out more in our article, “Can I bundle my Progressive car insurance with other policies?“
• High Rates for High-Risk Drivers: Drivers with poor records may face steep premiums, making new car replacements less accessible.

Enter your ZIP code below to compare cheap insurance rates.

Auto Home Health Life Business Motorcycle Pet Medicare Rental

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

#8 – State Farm: Best for Trusted Brand

Pros

• Comprehensive Coverage: State Farm offers broad coverage, including the best new car insurance, rates at $116/month.
  
• Discount Options: State Farm offers a 9% discount on new car replacement coverage.
  
• Strong Financial Backing: State Farm auto insurance review is known for its financial stability and long-standing industry reputation.

Cons

• Premium Costs: State Farm premiums might be higher compared to some competitors.
  
• Limited Online Discounts: Savings opportunities for online policies may be less generous, especially when considering new car replacement car insurance.

#9 – Geico: Best for Affordable Premiums

Pros

• Low Rates: Geico offers the lowest minimum coverage rates, at $$125/month, for auto replacement coverage.
  
• Discount Options: Geico provides an 8% discount for new car replacement coverage, making it affordable.
• Simple Online Process: Geico auto insurance review provides a user-friendly platform for quick quotes and claims for the best new car replacement car insurance.

Cons

• Customer Service: Some policyholders report slower responses in claims support.
  
• Fewer Bundling Options: Geico offers fewer bundling options than other insurers looking for replacement auto insurance.

#10 – AAA: Best for Member Benefits

Pros

• Additional Perks: AAA membership includes roadside assistance alongside auto replacement coverage rates at $95 monthly.
• Discount Options: AAA auto insurance review provides an attractive 10% discount for new car replacement coverage.
• Comprehensive Coverage: Policies are designed to serve as more expansive and better car replacement coverage.

Cons

• Membership Requirement: Coverage is only available to AAA members, adding car insurance costs with new car replacements.
  
• Limited Availability: Some states may have limited access to AAA’s best new car replacement coverage.

Enter your ZIP code below to compare cheap insurance rates.

Auto Home Health Life Business Motorcycle Pet Medicare Rental

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Best New Car Replacement Coverage by Rates and Ratios

When considering new car replacement insurance, monthly rates, and percentage ratios play a crucial role. Is new car replacement insurance worth it? It depends on how much you pay compared to what you get. Liberty Mutual has the highest rate at $130 and a 15% ratio, offering strong coverage. Erie is the most affordable at $110, with a 7% ratio, giving good value. Farmers and AAA charge $125, with a 12% ratio, focusing on coverage.

New Car Replacement Coverage by Monthly Rates & Percentage Ratio

Which car insurance companies offer new car replacements? Liberty Mutual, Erie, and Farmers are top providers. Geico and Amica offer a more affordable path for budget-conscious drivers, with rates of $112 and $115, respectively, and an 8% ratio. What is auto-replacement protection? It’s a feature that guarantees the replacement of your new car if it’s totaled, ensuring you aren’t left with an outdated vehicle or a lower payout than the cost of the car.

Liberty Mutual is ideal for full coverage, while Erie and Geico offer the most cost-effective plans. Progressive offers a balance with a 10% ratio and a $118 monthly rate. Comparing these options helps drivers find the best new car replacement plan.

What is New Car Replacement Insurance

New car replacement insurance gives car owners peace of mind by guaranteeing that if their new vehicle is totaled within a certain period, it will be replaced with a brand-new car of the same make and model. Insurance companies offer different coverage options, often based on the car’s age or mileage.

New Car Replacement Insurance Coverage Details by Provider

For example, AAA and American Family cover new cars under 1 year old, while Allstate and Erie extend this to vehicles under 2 years old. Some, like Liberty Mutual, even add mileage limits, covering cars with less than 15,000 miles.

Many insurers offer this coverage as part of their standard or optional plans. Geico covers cars in the first year of ownership, while Farmers and Erie do so within the first 2 years. Progressive offers new car replacement as an optional add-on, and State Farm’s comprehensive policies include it for qualifying vehicles, though it depends on the specific policy.

Knowing each provider’s specific rules is important for the best coverage. Some companies set mileage limits or have age-based eligibility, while others offer broader coverage. Choosing the right option helps avoid extra costs if your new car is totaled. To learn more, check out our comprehensive guide, “Best Car Insurance With Rental Reimbursement Coverage.”

Top Insurance Companies Offering the Best Discounts for New Car Replacement Coverage

Top insurance companies offer many discounts to lower the cost of new car replacement coverage. AAA provides savings like multi-policy, good drivers, new vehicles, and anti-theft discounts. Allstate offers similar deals, including safe driving, a new car, and anti-theft discounts to keep premiums affordable. American Family stands out with loyalty, good student, and defensive driving discounts.

Car Insurance Discounts From the Top Providers for New Car Replacement Coverage

Amica is known for its customer-friendly approach, offering loyalty, auto-pay, and good driver discounts. Erie helps policyholders save with paid-in-full, safe driver, and anti-theft discounts. Farmers focus on younger, safer drivers with good students, defensive driving, and safe driver discounts. Geico provides competitive savings with the military, good drivers, and defensive driving discounts.

Liberty Mutual offers vehicle safety, claims-free, and early shopper discounts. Progressive encourages savings with Snapshot, auto-pay, and good driver discounts. State Farm provides safe driver, good student, and defensive driving discounts, ensuring affordable options for all drivers. For additional insights, refer to our detailed guide titled “Does Liberty Mutual offer new car replacement coverage?”

Enter your ZIP code below to compare cheap insurance rates.

Auto Home Health Life Business Motorcycle Pet Medicare Rental

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

The Importance of New Car Replacement Coverage in Car Insurance

Having new car replacement car insurance is important for several reasons. First, knowing that you won’t suffer a major financial loss if your new car gets totaled offers peace of mind. Life is unpredictable, and accidents happen. With this coverage, you can rest easy knowing that you won’t be left empty-handed if the worst should occur.

Secondly, replacement auto insurance allows you to continue driving a brand-new car instead of settling for an older model or a used car. Let’s be honest; there is just something about a new car and that smell and the feeling of being the first owner. With this coverage, you could continue reaping the benefits of owning a brand-new car even after a tragic accident.

Lastly, auto replacement protection can save you from owing money on a car loan for a car you no longer have. Many people finance their new cars through loans, and if your car is totaled, you may still be responsible for paying off the remaining balance. However, with new car replacement insurance, you won’t have to worry about being stuck with a car loan for a vehicle that no longer exists.

In conclusion, new for old replacement car insurance is a very valuable add-on to the cost of car insurance. It can protect you financially, relieve worries, and allow an owner to drive a brand-new car after a car accident. So, the next time you shop for car insurance, inquire about new car replacement insurance and give yourself the reassurance you deserve.

Read More: Does American Family Home Insurance Company offer new car replacement coverage?

Factors to Consider When Choosing Car Insurance for New Car Replacement

When looking into vehicle replacement insurance, it’s important to understand the limits, costs, and rules. Policies may have restrictions like the car’s age, mileage, or the type of claim allowed. Be sure to compare premium costs and deductibles to find a plan that works for your budget and protects your car.

Coverage Limitations

It is important to examine the cover limits of each policy you are considering. While some policies will have age and mileage limitations, others are just going to do new car replacements for a certain number of years after an individual buys one.

It’s essential to read the fine print about what is not covered. Every single insurance policy has rules and regulations regarding car insurance and new car replacements. For example, some will only provide this coverage for up to three years for the car’s age, while others extend it up to five years.

Additionally, mileage may be limited so that when your car’s mileage exceeds a certain limit, you’ll no longer be covered for a replacement car. Knowing such details helps you make the right decision, ensuring you pick a policy aligned with your needs and expectations.

Deductibles

Consider the deductibles associated with new car replacement insurance. A higher deductible may result in lower premium rates but may also increase your out-of-pocket expenses in the event of a claim.

When it comes to deductibles, it’s all about finding the right balance. A deductible is the amount of money you have to pay out of pocket before your insurance kicks in. Choosing a higher deductible can lower your premium rates, making your insurance for new or old replacements more affordable.

However, you need to be able to afford this deductible should you get involved in an accident. Opting for a lower deductible may mean higher premium rates, but it can provide you with peace of mind, knowing that you won’t have to come up with a large sum of money if something happens to your new car.

Premium Rates

Compare premium rates for policies with new car replacement coverage. Keep in mind that the cost of this coverage may vary based on factors such as your location, driving record, and the make and model of your car.

When it comes to car insurance, new or old replacements, premium rates play a significant role in decision-making. The cost of auto replacement protection can vary depending on several factors. Your location is one of the key factors that insurance companies consider. If you live in an area with a high rate of car theft or accidents, you may pay more for this coverage.

Another factor is your record on the road. Most insurance companies welcome clients who are safe drivers, hence giving cheap premium rates to such customers. A clean sheet will naturally enable you to get cheap car insurance and new car replacement rates. The car’s make and model are also considered determinants of insurance cost. Expensive cars or cars that cost much to repair may attract costly insurance premiums.

Consequently, premium rates from various operators should be compared to determine the most economical coverage for your replacement car insurance.

Read More: Does Erie Insurance offer new car replacement coverage?

Top Car Insurance Companies for New Car Replacement Coverage

Now that you have understood the importance and considerations of new for old replacement car insurance, let’s take a closer look at some of the top car insurance companies that offer this valuable coverage.

The right insurance determines what is in store to protect the new car’s investment. New car replacement insurance provides that you will recover the full value of a brand-new car if your vehicle is totaled in a collision or stolen, not its depreciated value. This insurance for new or old replacements would be important and bring peace of mind and protection, mainly to someone who has recently purchased a new car.

Allstate Review

Allstate is another big car insurance company that has made a name for itself with good coverage options and customer satisfaction. They understand that everyone has a car with different needs and preferences, so they provide customizable policies according to individual requirements.

It offers new car replacement coverage as part of its packages. For example, if your new car gets wrecked or stolen, Allstate will replace it entirely with a completely new car.

Shout out to Allstate customers who use our Drivewise app! A national survey found, on average, Drivewise customers:
📞 handle their phones 44% less while driving
🚀 spend 23% less time driving at high speeds
🚙 have an 11% lower rate of hard braking https://t.co/5GeR2nydjm

— Allstate (@Allstate) April 19, 2024

In other words, you are assured of replacing it with a brand new one in case it gets stolen or wrecked, regardless of its depreciation value. That way, you do not have to accept a used car or bear any extra financial costs when replacing your vehicle. New car replacement insurance offers peace of mind, knowing you won’t be stuck with a used car after a total loss.

Farmers Review

Farmers are a popular choice among car owners seeking new car replacement coverage. Farmers have established itself as a reliable insurance provider with a wide range of policy options and competitive rates. If you choose Farmers, you can be sure of having full-range coverage for new car replacements.

Thus, in case your car gets totaled or stolen, there is full reimbursement for a brand-new one, and you can hit the road once again within a short time with minimal strain on your finances.

Additionally, Farmers know that car owners come from different backgrounds and have different budgets and coverage needs. Thus, they offer flexible policy options to customize your coverage to specific needs. Whether you own a luxury or budget-friendly car, Farmers has coverage. Car insurance new for old replacement means you don’t have to worry about depreciation or the hassle of settling for a used vehicle.

Amica Review

Amica is a highly reputable car insurance provider that offers comprehensive coverage options, including new car replacement coverage. With a strong focus on customer satisfaction, they have earned a reputation for excellent customer service and prompt claims handling. In addition to their exceptional service, they offer competitive rates, making them a top choice for many car owners.

When you choose Amica, you can rest assured that you will be well taken care of in the event of an accident or theft. Their new car replacement coverage ensures that you won’t have to worry about the financial burden of replacing your vehicle with a brand-new one.

This coverage is especially valuable for those who rely heavily on their cars for daily commuting or have a long commute to work. What insurance companies offer new car replacements? Amica is one of the top contenders, providing a reliable option for new car protection.

Read More: Does Amica Mutual Insurance offer new car replacement coverage?

In conclusion, new car replacement coverage should be considered when picking the best car insurance company to offer this precious protection, in addition to offering good customer service and favorable rates. Here, Amica, Allstate, and Farmers are at their best, meaning that these can ensure that you are driving peacefully, knowing your new ride is well protected from any roadside mishap.

How does new car replacement insurance work? These companies offer comprehensive options that safeguard your car from being depreciated, and you’ll drive away with a new vehicle should an accident or theft occur.

Enter your ZIP code below to compare cheap insurance rates.

Auto Home Health Life Business Motorcycle Pet Medicare Rental

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Compare Car Insurance Policies

When evaluating some car insurance policies that provide the best car replacement coverage, take several significant steps to make a fully informed decision. These include finding the best value in terms and conditions, comparing rates and coverage, and reviewing and rating customer reviews and ratings.

Comparing Rates and Coverage

The most important factor when comparing car insurance policies is quotes from multiple insurance companies. Comparing rates will also factor in coverage limits, deductibles, and any additional benefits the policies cover.While it might be tempting to choose the lowest price, ensuring that the coverage fits your needs is the right thing to do. Sometimes, paying more premiums will offer additional and complete coverage and greater peace of mind in the long run.

Read More: Rental Car Insurance & Collision Damage Waiver

Checking Customer Reviews and Ratings

When considering new car replacement coverage, customer reviews and ratings are key. They reveal how easy it is to file claims, customer service responsiveness, and coverage satisfaction. Pay attention to recurring themes, especially around claims handling.

Independent ratings from agencies like J.D. Power or A.M. Best also provide an unbiased view of financial stability and customer satisfaction, showing if a company can meet industry standards and pay claims. Combining both reviews and ratings helps you choose the right provider.

Case Studies: Real-Life Benefits of New Car Replacement Coverage

It is best to understand this new car replacement coverage by example; thus, three case studies are presented below as examples of how different individuals have utilized this insurance add-on to ease unexpected difficulties.

• Case Study #1 – Restoring Peace After a Total Loss: John, a Florida resident, totaled his SUV six months after purchase. His new car replacement coverage gave him a brand-new SUV of the same make and model, covering all costs and sparing him from financial strain.
• Case Study #2 – Financial Relief After Theft: Emily had her sedan stolen within a year of buying it. Under new car replacement coverage, she got a brand-new vehicle, which had little impact or eroded in value.
• Case Study #3 – A Lifeline for Loan Payments:  Mark’s car was wrecked. This left him owing $10,000 on his loan. The new car replacement coverage paid for a new car; Mark’s loan is now paid in full, and he carries no further bad debt.

These case studies highlight the importance of new car replacement coverage as a means of financial protection, peace of mind, and the capability to bounce back fast and respond to any shocks in life. Adding this cover to your policy may make a difference in difficult situations. Read more in our guide titled “Does Progressive Offer New Car Replacement Coverage?”

Ready to find the perfect plan? Get instant insurance quotes from our free comparison tool.

Enter your ZIP code below to compare cheap insurance rates.

Auto Home Health Life Business Motorcycle Pet Medicare Rental

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption